South Dakota Insurance Bad Faith Attorney
When an insurance company breaks its promise to act fairly and honestly, policyholders are left paying the price. At VandenBout Law, a Watertown insurance bad-faith law firm, we represent clients who have been misled, delayed, or flat-out denied by insurance companies who failed to honor their legal obligations. These actions aren’t just wrong—they may be unlawful.
Our firm knows how to confront insurers and demand accountability. We’ve seen firsthand how policyholders can be overwhelmed, frustrated, and left financially vulnerable. Our approach centers on personal attention, clear communication, and aggressive action against unethical insurance behavior.
What Is Insurance Bad Faith?
Bad faith happens when an insurance company violates the duty of good faith and fair dealing it owes to the policyholder. An insurer acts in bad faith when it unreasonably delays or denies a valid claim, misrepresents policy terms or puts profits ahead of people. This obligation exists in every insurance contract—even if it’s not spelled out in the paperwork. When you pay premiums, you enter into a relationship where the insurer owes you fair treatment.
In practice, bad faith may look like a company ignoring your calls, refusing to explain why a claim is denied, or delaying payments without cause. These tactics are more than business decisions—they can create lasting harm. At our firm, we push back with a deep understanding of how these strategies unfold and make sure our clients aren’t left in the dark.
These practices also confuse. Policyholders often feel powerless because they don’t understand what’s happening behind the scenes. They may second-guess themselves, assuming they missed something in the policy or didn’t submit the “right” paperwork. But the truth is that insurance companies count on this confusion to limit payouts.
Understanding Bad Faith in Massachusetts
In Massachusetts, insurance companies are legally required to treat claimants fairly throughout the claims process. Failure to do so may be considered bad faith under state law. Unlike some states, Massachusetts has robust protections for consumers who face unjust treatment from insurers.
The law not only expects insurers to act in good faith but also allows consumers to challenge unfair conduct and seek meaningful compensation. Our courts have consistently held that insurance companies cannot make arbitrary decisions. They must support their actions with clear reasoning and respect the terms of their policies.
This is particularly important for consumers who may not have legal training. The Massachusetts framework ensures that fairness isn’t just theoretical—it’s enforceable. Insurance companies operating in Massachusetts are on notice: deceptive conduct, unreasonable delays, and denials without basis can have steep consequences.
Chapter 176D and Your Legal Rights
In Massachusetts, Chapter 176D of the General Laws protects consumers from unfair and deceptive practices by insurance companies. This statute specifically outlines behaviors that constitute bad faith, including:
- Failing to promptly investigate claims
- Unreasonably delaying payment
- Not providing a reasonable explanation for claim denials
- Ignoring communication from policyholders
According to Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 176D, Section 3, it is unlawful for insurers to fail to acknowledge and act reasonably promptly upon communications concerning claims. If your insurance company is dragging its feet or failing to give clear answers, you may have grounds for legal action under Massachusetts law.
Our firm investigates these types of violations carefully. Reviewing every delay, excuse, and misstep, we build a picture of how an insurer has breached its obligations—often uncovering broader misconduct.
Signs That Your Provider Acted In Bad Faith
According to Chapter 176D, Section 3(9) of Massachusetts law, insurers must handle claims fairly and promptly. Under state law, practices like unreasonable delays or failure to investigate are defined as unfair claim settlement practices.
Delayed Payments
Unreasonable payment delays without clear justification often indicate bad faith. Insurers are required to process claims promptly. Waiting months for a check without explanation isn’t just frustrating—it may be a red flag.
We’ve worked with clients who waited nearly a year for payments that should have taken weeks. In those cases, the delay caused mounting debt, forced property sales, and worsened medical conditions. The harm goes far beyond inconvenience.
Sometimes, the delay is strategic. Insurers may hope the policyholder gives up, accepts a lowball offer, or misses a deadline. This delay doesn’t happen accidentally—it’s part of a wider pattern that deserves scrutiny.
Unreasonable Denial of Claims
When a valid claim is denied without clear or legitimate reasons, that’s a warning sign. Often, companies will rely on vague language or cite obscure exclusions that don’t apply.
Insurers sometimes use software to trigger automated denials without reviewing the facts. These practices may be standard procedures in the industry, but that doesn’t make them lawful. You have the right to challenge these decisions.
Our team has reviewed hundreds of denial letters, and a shocking number are almost identical—with cut-and-paste language, vague citations, and no real explanation. That’s not just lazy—it’s potentially unlawful.
Failure to Investigate Properly
Insurance companies must conduct a thorough and timely investigation. Ignoring evidence, failing to interview witnesses, or rubber-stamping denials without review is unacceptable.
We often see insurers assigning underqualified adjusters, failing to gather full records or outright misrepresenting facts. A rushed or biased investigation can spell disaster for claimants already under stress.
What Types of Claims Do Insurance Companies Deny?
It’s not just one kind of policy that’s affected. Insurers may deny claims across a wide range of coverage types.
Homeowners and Property Claims
Insurers may deny storm damage, fire claims, or water-related losses, citing wear and tear, poor maintenance, or unclear policy language. Often, the language in a denial letter may sound authoritative, but the reasoning may not hold up in court. This disconnect between policy language and real-world application often leaves homeowners feeling helpless—unsure whether their policy protects them.
Some of the most heartbreaking cases we’ve seen involve families who lost nearly everything in a house fire, only to be told their claim was “under investigation” for over a year. No updates. No payment. Just silence. During that time, families scrambled to find temporary housing, cover out-of-pocket expenses, and keep up with their mortgages. The emotional strain of being left in limbo after a traumatic loss is something no one should have to endure.
Auto Insurance Claims
Common denials involve liability disputes, failure to notify the insurer “on time,” or accusations of fraud—even when you’re the victim. In hit-and-run cases or multi-vehicle collisions, companies often shift blame to limit payouts. They may claim conflicting witness statements or suggest the accident could have been avoided—tactics that serve more to protect their bottom line than to seek the truth.
Auto claim denials also hit people during moments of crisis—after a serious accident, a theft, or a totaled vehicle. An unfair denial can leave someone without transportation, work, or access to medical treatment. In many cases, clients are left navigating complex repair estimates, rental fees, and medical appointments—all while trying to challenge the denial alone. That kind of pressure is exactly what insurers count on to wear people down.
Health and Disability Insurance Claims
Insurance carriers often challenge medical necessity, pre-existing conditions, or documentation—even when your doctor is fully on board. They may demand additional testing, require evaluations, or disregard your healthcare provider’s opinions. This process can become a bureaucratic maze, filled with repeated requests for the same documents and ambiguous medical reviews meant to stall or sidestep coverage decisions.
We’ve represented clients who had to cancel surgeries or delay life-saving treatments due to unjustified claim denials. That level of harm cannot be tolerated. When someone’s health is on the line, insurers should not be allowed to play games with paperwork or delay critical care simply to protect their profits.
Life Insurance Claims
Delays and denials often stem from alleged misrepresentations on the original application or disputes over the cause of death. In many cases, the policyholders can no longer defend themselves—leaving beneficiaries to fight for the promised benefits.
Insurers may comb through years of records looking for a technicality to avoid paying. These tactics only add to a grieving family’s burden. The result is not only a delayed financial recovery but a prolonged period of stress and uncertainty. Beneficiaries, already dealing with emotional loss, are forced into complex appeals processes that require legal guidance. We’ve seen families drained of energy and resources just trying to claim what is rightfully theirs.
What Are the Reasons Insurance Companies Deny Insurance Claims?
Insurance companies often deny claims for a variety of reasons—some legitimate, others questionable. Common justifications include:
Policy Exclusions
Insurance policies often exclude certain events or damages. However, insurers sometimes apply these broadly or inaccurately. What starts as a clause meant to limit risk can become a catch-all excuse to avoid paying legitimate claims. We’ve seen exclusions for “earth movement” used to deny damage caused by heavy rains or exclusions for flooding applied in situations where a burst pipe was covered. It’s critical to have a legal eye review the exact language of your policy.
Alleged Misrepresentations
Insurers may claim you omitted or misstated information when applying for coverage. This is one of the most frequently used justifications for denial. Often, the insurer will scrutinize the original application and try to connect minor errors or omissions to the reason for your claim—even if they’re unrelated. In some cases, policyholders are penalized for honest mistakes or misunderstandings. This tactic places all the risk on the consumer and undermines the purpose of having insurance in the first place.
Lack of Documentation
Missing paperwork or incomplete records can lead to a denied claim. However, an insurer has a duty to request needed documentation—not just deny your claim and move on. Moreover, they must explain what’s missing and give you a fair chance to provide it. Denying a claim without that opportunity is not just unfair—it’s grounds for legal action. Unfortunately, some insurers drag their feet, making multiple and confusing document requests, and then use the delay they created to reject your claim.
Bad Faith Tactics
Some companies rely on boilerplate reasons or outdated information to justify denials. These actions may appear legitimate but are designed to minimize payouts. Using vague denial language like “not covered under the terms of your policy” without citing specific clauses or offering follow-up guidance can leave policyholders confused and financially stuck. Repetition of these tactics across different claim types shows that denial isn’t the exception for some insurers—it’s the playbook.
Examples of Insurance Companies Acting in Bad Faith
How Bad Faith Practices Impact People in Watertown
Bad faith doesn’t just delay money—it disrupts lives. Our neighbors in Watertown struggle to stay afloat while waiting on insurance companies to honor their word. The emotional toll of being ignored or underpaid can be just as damaging as the financial hit. Children are affected, medical treatments are postponed, and families are forced into impossible decisions.
What to Do If an Insurer Acts Unfairly
According to United Policyholders, Massachusetts law requires insurers to “promptly investigate and pay or deny claims within a reasonable time.” A failure to do so could signal bad faith.
Can You Sue the Insurance Company?
Yes, you can file a lawsuit for insurance bad faith in Massachusetts. You may be entitled to compensation beyond the original value of your claim, including punitive damages in some cases. These lawsuits send a strong message that wrongful behavior won’t go unchecked. A court may also order additional relief if the insurance company’s actions were especially harmful or deceptive.
What Can You Recover If You Win?
Policyholders can recover the full value of the original claim, court costs, and potentially double or triple damages under Chapter 93A if the conduct was willful. In addition to compensatory damages, you may be able to recover attorney’s fees and receive interest on delayed payments. These recoveries are designed to fully restore what was lost—and hold insurers accountable for misconduct.
Is It Hard to Win a Bad Faith Case?
These cases take work, but success is possible when the facts are strong and properly documented. Insurers count on you not knowing your rights—we help even that playing field. Your chances improve significantly with the right legal strategy, proper documentation, and a thorough understanding of the insurer’s obligations. We focus on telling your story clearly, backed by the evidence that matters most.
What Types of Claims Do Insurance Companies Deny?
It’s not just one kind of policy that’s affected. Insurers may deny claims across a wide range of coverage types.
Homeowners and Property Claims
Insurers may deny storm damage, fire claims, or water-related losses, citing wear and tear, poor maintenance, or unclear policy language. Often, the language in a denial letter may sound authoritative, but the reasoning may not hold up in court. This disconnect between policy language and real-world application often leaves homeowners feeling helpless—unsure whether their policy protects them.
Some of the most heartbreaking cases we’ve seen involve families who lost nearly everything in a house fire, only to be told their claim was “under investigation” for over a year. No updates. No payment. Just silence. During that time, families scrambled to find temporary housing, cover out-of-pocket expenses, and keep up with their mortgages. The emotional strain of being left in limbo after a traumatic loss is something no one should have to endure.
Auto Insurance Claims
Common denials involve liability disputes, failure to notify the insurer “on time,” or accusations of fraud—even when you’re the victim. In hit-and-run cases or multi-vehicle collisions, companies often shift blame to limit payouts. They may claim conflicting witness statements or suggest the accident could have been avoided—tactics that serve more to protect their bottom line than to seek the truth.
Auto claim denials also hit people during moments of crisis—after a serious accident, a theft, or a totaled vehicle. An unfair denial can leave someone without transportation, work, or access to medical treatment. In many cases, clients are left navigating complex repair estimates, rental fees, and medical appointments—all while trying to challenge the denial alone. That kind of pressure is exactly what insurers count on to wear people down.
Health and Disability Insurance Claims
Insurance carriers often challenge medical necessity, pre-existing conditions, or documentation—even when your doctor is fully on board. They may demand additional testing, require evaluations, or disregard your healthcare provider’s opinions. This process can become a bureaucratic maze, filled with repeated requests for the same documents and ambiguous medical reviews meant to stall or sidestep coverage decisions.
We’ve represented clients who had to cancel surgeries or delay life-saving treatments due to unjustified claim denials. That level of harm cannot be tolerated. When someone’s health is on the line, insurers should not be allowed to play games with paperwork or delay critical care simply to protect their profits.
Life Insurance Claims
Delays and denials often stem from alleged misrepresentations on the original application or disputes over the cause of death. In many cases, the policyholders can no longer defend themselves—leaving beneficiaries to fight for the promised benefits.
Insurers may comb through years of records looking for a technicality to avoid paying. These tactics only add to a grieving family’s burden. The result is not only a delayed financial recovery but a prolonged period of stress and uncertainty. Beneficiaries, already dealing with emotional loss, are forced into complex appeals processes that require legal guidance. We’ve seen families drained of energy and resources just trying to claim what is rightfully theirs.
What Are the Reasons Insurance Companies Deny Insurance Claims?
Insurance companies often deny claims for a variety of reasons—some legitimate, others questionable. Common justifications include:
Policy Exclusions
Insurance policies often exclude certain events or damages. However, insurers sometimes apply these broadly or inaccurately. What starts as a clause meant to limit risk can become a catch-all excuse to avoid paying legitimate claims. We’ve seen exclusions for “earth movement” used to deny damage caused by heavy rains or exclusions for flooding applied in situations where a burst pipe was covered. It’s critical to have a legal eye review the exact language of your policy.
Alleged Misrepresentations
Insurers may claim you omitted or misstated information when applying for coverage. This is one of the most frequently used justifications for denial. Often, the insurer will scrutinize the original application and try to connect minor errors or omissions to the reason for your claim—even if they’re unrelated. In some cases, policyholders are penalized for honest mistakes or misunderstandings. This tactic places all the risk on the consumer and undermines the purpose of having insurance in the first place.
Lack of Documentation
Missing paperwork or incomplete records can lead to a denied claim. However, an insurer has a duty to request needed documentation—not just deny your claim and move on. Moreover, they must explain what’s missing and give you a fair chance to provide it. Denying a claim without that opportunity is not just unfair—it’s grounds for legal action. Unfortunately, some insurers drag their feet, making multiple and confusing document requests, and then use the delay they created to reject your claim.
Bad Faith Tactics
Some companies rely on boilerplate reasons or outdated information to justify denials. These actions may appear legitimate but are designed to minimize payouts. Using vague denial language like “not covered under the terms of your policy” without citing specific clauses or offering follow-up guidance can leave policyholders confused and financially stuck. Repetition of these tactics across different claim types shows that denial isn’t the exception for some insurers—it’s the playbook.
Examples of Insurance Companies Acting in Bad Faith
How Bad Faith Practices Impact People in Watertown
Bad faith doesn’t just delay money—it disrupts lives. Our neighbors in Watertown struggle to stay afloat while waiting on insurance companies to honor their word. The emotional toll of being ignored or underpaid can be just as damaging as the financial hit. Children are affected, medical treatments are postponed, and families are forced into impossible decisions.
What to Do If an Insurer Acts Unfairly
According to United Policyholders, Massachusetts law requires insurers to “promptly investigate and pay or deny claims within a reasonable time.” A failure to do so could signal bad faith.
Can You Sue the Insurance Company?
Yes, you can file a lawsuit for insurance bad faith in Massachusetts. You may be entitled to compensation beyond the original value of your claim, including punitive damages in some cases. These lawsuits send a strong message that wrongful behavior won’t go unchecked. A court may also order additional relief if the insurance company’s actions were especially harmful or deceptive.
What Can You Recover If You Win?
Policyholders can recover the full value of the original claim, court costs, and potentially double or triple damages under Chapter 93A if the conduct was willful. In addition to compensatory damages, you may be able to recover attorney’s fees and receive interest on delayed payments. These recoveries are designed to fully restore what was lost—and hold insurers accountable for misconduct.
Is It Hard to Win a Bad Faith Case?
These cases take work, but success is possible when the facts are strong and properly documented. Insurers count on you not knowing your rights—we help even that playing field. Your chances improve significantly with the right legal strategy, proper documentation, and a thorough understanding of the insurer’s obligations. We focus on telling your story clearly, backed by the evidence that matters most.
What Types of Claims Do Insurance Companies Deny?
It’s not just one kind of policy that’s affected. Insurers may deny claims across a wide range of coverage types.
Homeowners and Property Claims
Insurers may deny storm damage, fire claims, or water-related losses, citing wear and tear, poor maintenance, or unclear policy language. Often, the language in a denial letter may sound authoritative, but the reasoning may not hold up in court. This disconnect between policy language and real-world application often leaves homeowners feeling helpless—unsure whether their policy protects them.
Some of the most heartbreaking cases we’ve seen involve families who lost nearly everything in a house fire, only to be told their claim was “under investigation” for over a year. No updates. No payment. Just silence. During that time, families scrambled to find temporary housing, cover out-of-pocket expenses, and keep up with their mortgages. The emotional strain of being left in limbo after a traumatic loss is something no one should have to endure.
Auto Insurance Claims
Common denials involve liability disputes, failure to notify the insurer “on time,” or accusations of fraud—even when you’re the victim. In hit-and-run cases or multi-vehicle collisions, companies often shift blame to limit payouts. They may claim conflicting witness statements or suggest the accident could have been avoided—tactics that serve more to protect their bottom line than to seek the truth.
Auto claim denials also hit people during moments of crisis—after a serious accident, a theft, or a totaled vehicle. An unfair denial can leave someone without transportation, work, or access to medical treatment. In many cases, clients are left navigating complex repair estimates, rental fees, and medical appointments—all while trying to challenge the denial alone. That kind of pressure is exactly what insurers count on to wear people down.
Health and Disability Insurance Claims
Insurance carriers often challenge medical necessity, pre-existing conditions, or documentation—even when your doctor is fully on board. They may demand additional testing, require evaluations, or disregard your healthcare provider’s opinions. This process can become a bureaucratic maze, filled with repeated requests for the same documents and ambiguous medical reviews meant to stall or sidestep coverage decisions.
We’ve represented clients who had to cancel surgeries or delay life-saving treatments due to unjustified claim denials. That level of harm cannot be tolerated. When someone’s health is on the line, insurers should not be allowed to play games with paperwork or delay critical care simply to protect their profits.
Life Insurance Claims
Delays and denials often stem from alleged misrepresentations on the original application or disputes over the cause of death. In many cases, the policyholders can no longer defend themselves—leaving beneficiaries to fight for the promised benefits.
Insurers may comb through years of records looking for a technicality to avoid paying. These tactics only add to a grieving family’s burden. The result is not only a delayed financial recovery but a prolonged period of stress and uncertainty. Beneficiaries, already dealing with emotional loss, are forced into complex appeals processes that require legal guidance. We’ve seen families drained of energy and resources just trying to claim what is rightfully theirs.
What Are the Reasons Insurance Companies Deny Insurance Claims?
Insurance companies often deny claims for a variety of reasons—some legitimate, others questionable. Common justifications include:
Policy Exclusions
Insurance policies often exclude certain events or damages. However, insurers sometimes apply these broadly or inaccurately. What starts as a clause meant to limit risk can become a catch-all excuse to avoid paying legitimate claims. We’ve seen exclusions for “earth movement” used to deny damage caused by heavy rains or exclusions for flooding applied in situations where a burst pipe was covered. It’s critical to have a legal eye review the exact language of your policy.
Alleged Misrepresentations
Insurers may claim you omitted or misstated information when applying for coverage. This is one of the most frequently used justifications for denial. Often, the insurer will scrutinize the original application and try to connect minor errors or omissions to the reason for your claim—even if they’re unrelated. In some cases, policyholders are penalized for honest mistakes or misunderstandings. This tactic places all the risk on the consumer and undermines the purpose of having insurance in the first place.
Lack of Documentation
Missing paperwork or incomplete records can lead to a denied claim. However, an insurer has a duty to request needed documentation—not just deny your claim and move on. Moreover, they must explain what’s missing and give you a fair chance to provide it. Denying a claim without that opportunity is not just unfair—it’s grounds for legal action. Unfortunately, some insurers drag their feet, making multiple and confusing document requests, and then use the delay they created to reject your claim.
Bad Faith Tactics
Some companies rely on boilerplate reasons or outdated information to justify denials. These actions may appear legitimate but are designed to minimize payouts. Using vague denial language like “not covered under the terms of your policy” without citing specific clauses or offering follow-up guidance can leave policyholders confused and financially stuck. Repetition of these tactics across different claim types shows that denial isn’t the exception for some insurers—it’s the playbook.
Examples of Insurance Companies Acting in Bad Faith
How Bad Faith Practices Impact People in Watertown
Bad faith doesn’t just delay money—it disrupts lives. Our neighbors in Watertown struggle to stay afloat while waiting on insurance companies to honor their word. The emotional toll of being ignored or underpaid can be just as damaging as the financial hit. Children are affected, medical treatments are postponed, and families are forced into impossible decisions.
What to Do If an Insurer Acts Unfairly
According to United Policyholders, Massachusetts law requires insurers to “promptly investigate and pay or deny claims within a reasonable time.” A failure to do so could signal bad faith.
Can You Sue the Insurance Company?
Yes, you can file a lawsuit for insurance bad faith in Massachusetts. You may be entitled to compensation beyond the original value of your claim, including punitive damages in some cases. These lawsuits send a strong message that wrongful behavior won’t go unchecked. A court may also order additional relief if the insurance company’s actions were especially harmful or deceptive.
What Can You Recover If You Win?
Policyholders can recover the full value of the original claim, court costs, and potentially double or triple damages under Chapter 93A if the conduct was willful. In addition to compensatory damages, you may be able to recover attorney’s fees and receive interest on delayed payments. These recoveries are designed to fully restore what was lost—and hold insurers accountable for misconduct.
Is It Hard to Win a Bad Faith Case?
These cases take work, but success is possible when the facts are strong and properly documented. Insurers count on you not knowing your rights—we help even that playing field. Your chances improve significantly with the right legal strategy, proper documentation, and a thorough understanding of the insurer’s obligations. We focus on telling your story clearly, backed by the evidence that matters most.
Why You Need an Experienced Watertown Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer
Local Experience with Massachusetts Laws
Massachusetts insurance law is nuanced. We’ve studied how insurers operate locally and understand how to interpret their actions under Chapters 176D and 93A.
We don’t just file paperwork—we investigate thoroughly, speak with relevant parties, and build claims that insurers take seriously.
Contact a Watertown Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer Now
Free Consultation: Let’s Review Your Case
Whether you’re facing delays or outright denial, let’s talk. Our team at a trusted Watertown Insurance bad faith law firm can evaluate the situation and offer insight on the next steps—no pressure, no obligation.
Leave Us a Message
Fill out our online form with a few details about your case. We’ll review everything thoroughly and get back to you shortly to schedule a time to speak with our team.
Contact Us Now
Call us today at (720) 713-3415 to speak directly with someone from our Watertown Insurance bad faith law firm. Getting help from a team who understands how these companies operate can make all the difference.